Star One - Live on Earth

 

Cover

Musicians

Star One - Live on Earth

Russell Allen : vocals
Damian Wilson : vocals
Floor Jansen : vocals
Irene Jansen : vocals
Robert Soeterboek : vocals
Ed Warby : drums
Peter Vink : bass
Joost van den Broek : keyboards
Arjen Anthony Lucassen : guitars, synth, vocals
Ewa Alberling : flute
 
Release  Label Cat. N°:  Playing Time Rating
2003 Inside Out IOMCD 121
SPV 089-65722 DCD
CD1: 53'48"
CD2: 60'14"
Clayreon : 9/10
Jany : 9/10

Website

Contact

Style

 Ayreon

-

Space Metal

Review by : Claude 'Clayreon' Bosschem
Translation by : Danny 'Camil' Focke

Review by : John 'Bobo' Bollenberg


Clayreon : Over and over again, The Dutch musical centipede Arjen Lucassen succeeds to present something new to his fans. He started heavier with Vengeance and released some splendid progressive metal, concept albums as Ayreon, each time accompanied by an elite of musicians and vocalists. He turned a bit more quiet with Ambeon, the ambient/Ayreon project with the young but very talented Astrid van der Veen. And then the space metal-project Star One turned up. After the first time I heard it, I wasn’t completely convinced because it was a bit too metal for me. But after the gig of Star One in Hof Ter Loo in Antwerp, I was definitively sold for this project. And I better admit it right away, I’m a real Ayreon fan, just take a look at my nickname.

Fortunately, this unique concert was recorded and now released on a double album. The recordings were made in Rijssen (Holland) but the set list is almost the same as on the other 6 gigs in Belgium, Germany and Holland. The least you can say, is that the concerts were unique, because Arjen doesn’t appear live that often. Each Ayreon fan was waiting for years for this to happen. If you couldn’t be there during the autumn of 2002, you can wash away your tears by buying this live double-CD, which will also be released as a limited edition with a bonus-DVD that contains footage of the gig. It’s a pity, the DVD wasn’t included in the promo, but according to the mailing list of Ayreon, the DVD is also brilliant.

Arjen called on vocalists Russell Allen (Symphony X), Damian Wilson (Threshold), the Jansen sisters (After Forever) and Robert Soeterboek (Wicked Sensation) who replaced Dan Swanö (Nightingale). Because of the heterogeneity of the musicians, there wasn’t a lot of time to rehearse, but no one noticed it during the shows. It seemed as if they were touring together for years.

And what about the set list? Almost the whole Star One was set loose on the public, but a lot of them were there to hear some typical Ayreon songs. When you listen to this CD, it’s as if you’re experiencing the whole concert again. The sound is marvellous, the production is splendid and the public is enthusiast. The public even succeeded in staying silent during the quiet pieces, but after that, they bursted into cheering their idols. It’s unbelievable, how they succeeded in showing the instruments to full advantage, which I’m missing on many other live CD’s.

Although the complete band is convincing enough, I would like to specially mention some of the individual contributions. First of all, there’s the strong performance of Sir Russell Allen. What a powerful voice and what a great charisma the man has! I was also enormously charmed by the, unknown to me, but very talented, young keyboard player Joost van den Broek from Sun Caged. And last but not least, the man who’s in the centre of it all, Arjen Lucassen himself, who is one of the appealing musicians within the progressive metal style, with his beautiful compositions and his flawless guitar playing. A guitarist who doesn’t tinkle endlessly, but who has an eye for the melody, even during the heavy tracks.

The set list is a mix of Star One and Ayreon songs and can hardly be called a real rock opera, although the alternating appearances of the different vocalists point a bit in that direction. Off course, the whole show stands in connection with the great passion of Ayreon, science fiction and space. Just listen to the narrated pieces.

The whole concert is one highlight, but maybe I can pin-point some special moments.

After the predictable “Lift Off”, the gig starts with the heavy metal track “Set Your Controls”, which reminds me often of Deep Purple, but the solos of Lucassen and van den Broek immediately set fire to the show.

During ‘Songs of the Ocean’, there’s a first real interaction with the public, and the chorus is sung along by everyone. This happens again in “The Eye Of Ra”. (The Seventh Sign).

In “The Dream Sequencer” Arjen Lucassen himself, conjures a beautiful guitar solo out of his sleeves, followed by the equal beauty of “Into The Black Hole”, one of my favourite Ayreon-songs.

Once more, there’s a very strong vocal performance by Russell Allen in “Dawn of a Million Souls”.

The bluesy “Intergalactic Space Crusader” is a breathtaking duel between Arjen and Joost, which you can only experience at a live gig.

“Isis and Osiris” with the guest performance of Ewa Albering (ex-Quidam). 

“The Two Gates” with the introduction of the band, on a strong groove and with the necessary humour.

The only minus on this album is the not always consistent vocal performance of Robert Soeterboek, but this is largely compensated by Russell Allen.

We must certainly not forget the splendid art-work by Mattias Norén.

Do I need to mention it? This is an absolute must for every Ayreon fan!

It’s a pity, I can’t judge the bonus DVD. This live double-CD belongs to the best live albums ever made, both qua production, compositions and the quality of the musicians. Perfectionist Arjen will discover some minor mistakes, but for me this is top! You should be in the shop already!!


Bobo: When I heard the Star One studio album for the very first time I knew there would be a live performance one day. The music on this disc compared with the Ayreon material was more suitable to be performed with a real live band. I guess the fact Arjen uses loads of different vocalists kind of mortgages the possibilities to go on the road. So when the word was out that Star One was doing a tour which encompassed seven days of course I needed to see the band at least once. I got to see them in Antwerp, Belgium yet as a souvenir of this short tour a double live CD has been released recorded during the last day of the tour in Rijsen, Holland. Arjen told me it was impossible to take this thing on the road anywhere else except Holland, Belgium and Germany as was done this time around. The huge expenses didn’t make it possible to take this experience to America for instance although of course everyone in this ‘occasional band’ would jump at the chance to fly to the States for an extensive tour. Or to South-America, or Japan or Australia for that matter. In order to do well for those fans who didn’t get to see the shows there’s the live album with the limited edition also containing a DVD with the entire show, some additional footage and their superb rendition of the Deep Purple classic ‘Space truckin’ and other extra’s.

Exactly one year after the release of the studio album comes the Star One live double set “Live on earth” and you can hear on the album that all individual members had great fun in doing this. For Arjen it must have been a dream come true as it’s not that obvious to get all of this on the road. When I saw the band in Antwerp the sound was way too loud so a lot of details were lost in the mix. Luckily here in Rijsen the mix is perfect which is a great compliment to the address of the people ‘behind the scenes’. It’s not an easy task to mix five vocalists (six if you include Arjen), the powerful drums of Ed Warby and the flashy metalic guitars of Lucassen but they have done a great job. Although of course the material from “Space metal” is ideal to be performed live, the band also tackled several Ayreon ‘classics’ to great delight. Hear Sir Russell Allen sing ‘Dreamtime’ from the acclaimed debut album “The final experiment” which originally was sung by Edward Reekers. Together with the Jansen sisters singing backing vocals this is such a wonderful song ! The great thing about using different singers is that you can chose who does which part so that it fits certain atmospheres best. The rocker ‘Songs of the ocean’ is the ideal cup of tea for the raunchy voice of Robert Soeterboek who at times sounds a little like David Coverdale.

For sure the BIG surprise of the evening was the talent of keyboardplayer Joost Van Den Broek, member of Sun Caged. Apart from Ryo Okumoto I know very little keyboardplayers who are such party animals like Joost so you’d better check out the DVD if you want to see it for yourself ! Next to being a real showman he is also very, and I mean VERY, talented. Being the youngest in the band his rack stood next to that of bassplayer Peter Vink whom in turn was the oldest of the company which once again illustrates that great music can be performed and digested by ALL ages ! I really like the deep Hammond sounds Joost uses throughout the performance. I’m not sure however whether at all everything you hear on this album is truly what has been recorded that very same night on october 5th, 2002 as for instance the voice which preceeds ‘The dream sequencer’ sounds very cristalclear as if it was pasted from the original mastertape. The song itself remains a fantastic ‘pièce de résistance’ for Arjen’s talent as a guitarplayer and a feast for guitarlovers the world over. The quality of our beloved backing vocalists is apparent during the magnum opus ‘Into the black hole’ culminating in some heavy riffs to great delight of the enthousiastic crowd. Although obviously it’s the pure rocksongs which have the audience sing and move along there’s also room for some softer material. Introducing Ewa Smarzynska on flute especially ‘Valley of the queens’ results in one of the nicest songs on the planet ! Since leaving Quidam and Poland, Ewa now resides in Holland where she has become Ewa Albering. Her flute and the angelic voices of the Jansen sisters together with some harpsichord sounds out of Joost’s archive for me deliver the highlight of the entire set.

Over to the second disc of the set which opens with the ending sequence of the first disc so you can actually turn this into one ongoing ‘saga’ if you have two CD-players switched on at the same time that is. Again it’s Ewa’s fluteplaying which introduces a decent folk influence during ‘Isis and Osiris’ with once again an outstanding Russell Allen. Here Joost’s organplaying gets close to the sound of Jon Lord. When Arjen sings part of ‘Amazing flight in space’ I can’t help think about his tribute CD issued under the moniker of Strange Hobby because the way he sings his part gets close to the authentic sixties feel. The highlight here however is the part where Arjen and Joost deliver a musical battle with Arjen on guitar and Joost on keytar. On DVD this should be pure magic and illustrates perfectly the show element tucked away deep inside Joost’s body. The actual set closes with ‘The eye of Ra’ which is a very daring experience knowing the song closes in pure a capella mode. The band gets back on stage for an encore which consists of ‘Starchild’ and ‘The two gates’. During the latter Russell introduces the full band whilst Soeterboeks’ voice reminds me of the song ‘Old blind mole’ on the “Butterfly ball” album and Damian’s voice sounds like a young Robert Plant. For a final time each individual member of starship Star One gives his very best so the set closes with the biggest exclamation mark in the history of rockmusic. With “Live on earth” Arjen Lucassen proves that you don’t need to hop on a plane direction Japan to deliver an outstanding live album. The ‘made in Japan’ live albums are truly over !

 

 

Tracklist

CD 1
01. Lift-Off
02. Set Your Controls
03. High Moon
04. Dreamtime
05. Eyes Of Time
06. Songs Of The Ocean
07. Dawn Of A Million Souls
08. The Dream Sequenzer
09. Into The Black Hole
10. Actual Fantasy
11. Valley Of The Queens
CD 2
01. Isis And Osiris
02. Amazing Flight In Space
03. Intergalactic Space Crusader
04. Castle Hall
05. The Eye Of Ra
06. Starchild
07. The Two Gates


 

 

Website in order to promote progressive rock to a broader audience in Flanders but also in the entire world. No part from this website may be used in any other publication whether in print or on the world wide web without the editor's consent - all material is exclusive to Prog-Nose and copyright protected.

Last updated: 23 februari 2004 .
All rights reserved. Copyright © Prog-Nose 30/05/2001.